When a police officer is found not guilty of criminal charges after a shooting or other use of force, victims and their families may assume the verdict ends their opportunity to seek legal accountability.
That is not necessarily the case.
A criminal acquittal does not automatically prevent a separate civil rights lawsuit. Criminal prosecutions and civil cases operate under different laws, burdens of proof, procedures, and potential remedies.
The distinction is particularly relevant following the acquittal of former Okaloosa County sheriff’s deputy Eddie Duran in the death of U.S. Air Force Senior Airman Roger Fortson.
An Okaloosa County jury found Duran not guilty of manslaughter. Fortson’s family, however, has a separate federal civil rights lawsuit pending against Duran, Okaloosa County Sheriff Eric Aden, and others. The source press release expressly states that the federal case is separate from the criminal trial. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Attorney Ben Crump confirmed following the verdict that Fortson’s family intends to continue pursuing that litigation. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Read what happens next in the Roger Fortson case following Eddie Duran’s acquittal.
The Fortson case illustrates a broader legal principle: “not guilty” in criminal court and “not liable” in civil court are not the same determination.
Can You Sue a Police Officer After a Not-Guilty Verdict?
Potentially.
Whether a civil lawsuit is available depends on the facts, the alleged violation, the defendants, the evidence, applicable federal and state law, and relevant filing deadlines.
But a criminal acquittal does not, by itself, eliminate the possibility of civil litigation.
That is because the criminal prosecution and civil lawsuit generally answer different legal questions.
A criminal trial determines whether the government has proven the charged crime under the demanding criminal burden of proof.
A civil rights lawsuit may instead examine whether a government official violated a person’s federally protected rights and whether that violation caused legally compensable harm.
Those are separate inquiries.
Why Can a Civil Case Continue After a Criminal Acquittal?
One major reason is the burden of proof.
In a criminal prosecution, the government generally must prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Civil claims generally operate under a lower burden of proof, although the precise standard depends on the claim.
A civil jury is also not necessarily deciding whether the defendant committed the same offense considered during the criminal trial.
Instead, the civil litigation may concern constitutional violations, wrongful death, negligence, or other causes of action.
This means a criminal jury can acquit an officer without necessarily resolving every issue that could arise in a civil lawsuit.
What Does “Not Guilty” Actually Mean for a Civil Case?
A not-guilty verdict means the prosecution did not obtain a criminal conviction on the charge considered by the jury.
It should not automatically be interpreted to mean:
- no wrongful conduct occurred;
- no constitutional violation could have occurred;
- the officer cannot face civil liability;
- the family has no civil claim, or
- the evidence cannot support a different legal claim under a different burden of proof.
At the same time, an acquittal does not mean a subsequent civil lawsuit will succeed.
The plaintiff must still prove the elements of the civil claims asserted.
The proper conclusion is narrower: the criminal verdict and potential civil liability are separate legal questions.
What Is a Section 1983 Civil Rights Lawsuit?
One of the principal federal statutes used in litigation alleging constitutional violations by state and local officials is 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
Section 1983 can provide a mechanism for bringing certain civil claims when a person acting under color of state law allegedly violates rights protected by the U.S. Constitution or federal law.
Police-related §1983 litigation can involve allegations concerning:
- excessive or unreasonable force;
- unlawful searches or seizures;
- failure to intervene;
- unconstitutional policies or practices;
- inadequate training or supervision in circumstances satisfying the applicable legal requirements; or
- other violations of federally protected rights.
The existence of a police shooting does not automatically establish a §1983 violation.
The plaintiff must establish the elements of the particular constitutional claim.
People researching these cases can learn more through Ben Crump Law’s civil rights lawyer resource.
Can an Excessive Force Lawsuit Continue After an Officer Is Acquitted?
Potentially.
A criminal prosecution for an offense such as manslaughter and a federal excessive-force claim do not necessarily require proof of the same legal elements.
An excessive-force claim involving law enforcement generally focuses on whether the officer’s use of force violated the constitutional standard applicable to the encounter.
The criminal case instead focuses on whether the prosecution established the elements of the charged crime beyond a reasonable doubt.
Because the questions differ, an acquittal on a criminal charge does not automatically resolve an excessive-force claim.
The civil court must evaluate that claim under the law governing the alleged constitutional violation.
How Does This Apply to the Roger Fortson Case?
The proceedings following Roger Fortson’s death provide a current example.
Fortson was a 23-year-old U.S. Air Force Senior Airman assigned to the 4th Special Operations Squadron at Hurlburt Field. Former Okaloosa County sheriff’s deputy Eddie Duran shot and killed Fortson at his Fort Walton Beach apartment on May 3, 2024.
The Okaloosa County Sheriff’s Office fired Duran less than a month later, and Florida’s First Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office charged him with manslaughter. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
A jury subsequently acquitted Duran.
But before that criminal trial concluded, Fortson’s family had already filed separate federal civil litigation.
In May 2025, the family filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against Duran, Sheriff Eric Aden, and others. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Read Ben Crump Law’s original announcement of the Roger Fortson federal lawsuit.
Following the acquittal, Crump said:
“Roger’s life and his service will always matter. His family will keep fighting for him, and we will stand with them as they pursue their civil rights case in federal court and seek accountability for the tragic loss of his life.”
Read Ben Crump’s complete statement following the Eddie Duran verdict.
Does an Acquittal Make a Civil Lawsuit Harder?
It can affect the litigation, but its significance depends on the case.
Attorneys may need to evaluate what evidence was presented during the criminal trial, what findings the verdict actually resolved, what evidence may be available in the civil proceeding, and whether testimony or records developed during the prosecution are relevant.
A criminal acquittal may also influence public perception or litigation strategy.
But it does not substitute for the legal analysis required in the civil case.
The civil lawsuit still turns on its own:
- causes of action;
- evidentiary record;
- defendants;
- legal standards;
- defenses;
- burden of proof; and
- damages.
For that reason, attorneys evaluating a potential civil claim must examine the underlying facts rather than relying solely on the outcome of the criminal prosecution.
What if Prosecutors Never Charge the Officer?
The same general distinction can matter when prosecutors decide not to bring criminal charges at all.
A decision not to prosecute does not automatically establish that no civil rights claim exists.
Prosecutors must determine whether the available evidence can establish a criminal offense under the applicable criminal standard.
A civil attorney may be evaluating different legal claims under different standards.
That is why civil litigation can sometimes proceed even when:
- prosecutors decline charges;
- a grand jury declines to indict;
- charges are dismissed; or
- a criminal jury returns a not-guilty verdict.
Each situation has its own legal and factual implications, but none should automatically be treated as a definitive answer to whether a separate civil claim exists.
Ben Crump Law also maintains a more specific resource that explains what may happen when a grand jury declines to bring criminal charges.
Can a City or Sheriff’s Department Be Sued Even if the Officer Is Acquitted?
Potentially, but claims against government entities involve additional legal requirements.
Under federal civil rights law, a municipality is not automatically liable simply because it employed an officer accused of unconstitutional conduct.
Depending on the allegations, a plaintiff seeking to establish municipal liability may need to prove that a governmental policy, custom, practice, or other legally recognized basis for municipal liability caused the constitutional violation.
Cases may therefore involve investigation of issues such as:
- written policies;
- training;
- supervision;
- disciplinary practices;
- prior incidents;
- patterns of similar conduct; or
- decisions by officials with relevant policymaking authority.
The precise requirements depend on the claims and governing law.
This is another reason a criminal trial against an individual officer may not resolve all of the questions presented in subsequent civil litigation.
Is a Civil Rights Lawsuit the Same as a Wrongful Death Lawsuit?
No, although the claims can sometimes be pursued together.
A federal civil rights lawsuit may focus on whether a government official violated constitutional or federally protected rights.
A wrongful death claim generally arises under state law and concerns a death allegedly caused by conduct meeting the state’s requirements for liability.
A fatal police encounter can potentially involve both types of claims.
State survival law may also affect which claims continue following a person’s death and which damages can be pursued.
Ben Crump Law provides additional information about wrongful death claims.
What Evidence Can Be Used in the Civil Case?
Civil rights attorneys may investigate much of the same underlying evidence considered during a criminal prosecution while evaluating it for different legal purposes.
Potential evidence can include:
- body-camera footage;
- dashboard-camera footage;
- surveillance recordings;
- cellphone video;
- 911 and dispatch recordings;
- police reports;
- witness testimony;
- photographs;
- forensic evidence;
- medical and autopsy records;
- use-of-force policies;
- training records;
- disciplinary records;
- deposition testimony; and
- expert analysis.
Evidence developed during the criminal proceedings may also become relevant to the civil litigation when legally obtainable and admissible.
The central question is whether the available evidence establishes the elements of the civil claims, not whether prosecutors previously obtained a criminal conviction.
What Can a Family Seek Through a Civil Rights Lawsuit?
A civil lawsuit provides remedies different from criminal punishment.
When liability is established, plaintiffs may potentially seek compensatory damages for legally recognized losses caused by the violation.
Depending on the case and the defendant, damages may include medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, emotional harm, and other compensable losses.
Fatal cases can raise additional wrongful death and survival damages questions.
Punitive damages may also be available against certain individual defendants in federal civil rights cases when the governing standard is satisfied.
However, there is no standard value for a police shooting or civil rights lawsuit.
The third article in this cluster examines those issues directly:
Fatal Police Shooting Lawsuit: What Damages May Be Available?
Does a Civil Lawsuit Punish the Officer for the Same Crime?
Not in the same way.
Criminal prosecution is designed to determine criminal guilt and, when guilt is established, impose criminal penalties.
Civil litigation addresses civil liability and civil remedies.
Punitive damages may be available in civil rights litigation against individual defendants, but they are a civil remedy governed by their own legal standard. They are not another criminal conviction or prison sentence.
Compensatory damages serve a different purpose: compensating plaintiffs for legally recognized injuries and losses caused by the defendant’s conduct.
Understanding those differences helps explain why criminal and civil proceedings can arise from the same incident without being the same case.
Does the Criminal Verdict Determine How Much a Civil Case Is Worth?
No.
An acquittal does not assign a monetary value to a civil claim.
Nor does the existence of a civil lawsuit establish that damages will ultimately be recovered.
The potential value of a civil case depends on factors such as:
- whether liability can be established;
- the nature and severity of the harm;
- economic losses;
- noneconomic damages permitted by law;
- the defendants involved;
- whether punitive damages are legally available;
- the evidence supporting damages; and
- applicable federal and state law.
The outcome of another police misconduct case cannot establish what a different case is worth.
For a detailed examination of damages following a fatal police encounter, see Fatal Police Shooting Lawsuit: What Damages May Be Available?.
What Should Families Do After an Officer Is Acquitted?
Families considering civil litigation should not assume the criminal verdict answers every potential civil question.
A civil rights attorney can independently examine the evidence and determine whether the facts may support federal civil rights, wrongful death, survival, or other available claims.
That review may include:
- obtaining and preserving video and other evidence;
- reviewing the criminal case record;
- identifying potential defendants;
- analyzing the applicable constitutional standard;
- evaluating potential municipal liability;
- determining what state-law claims may exist;
- evaluating potential damages; and
- identifying applicable statutes of limitation and special notice deadlines.
Those deadlines are particularly important.
Families should not assume that a criminal investigation or prosecution automatically pauses the deadline for filing a civil lawsuit.
The Roger Fortson Case Shows Why Criminal and Civil Cases Must Be Evaluated Separately
The current Fortson proceedings provide a straightforward illustration.
Duran faced a state manslaughter prosecution and was acquitted.
Fortson’s family has a separate federal civil rights case.
Following the criminal verdict, the family’s attorney publicly confirmed that they intend to continue pursuing that lawsuit. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Those facts do not determine how the federal lawsuit will ultimately be resolved.
They do demonstrate why the criminal verdict should not be treated as though it automatically disposed of the separate civil case.
For the latest case chronology, read:
Eddie Duran Acquitted: What Happens Next in the Roger Fortson Case?
For Ben Crump’s response on behalf of the family, read:
Attorney Ben Crump Responds to Verdict in Death of Senior Airman Roger Fortson
For the compensation side of civil litigation, read:
Fatal Police Shooting Lawsuit: What Damages May Be Available?
Talk to a Civil Rights Attorney About a Police Shooting Claim
A criminal acquittal can be devastating for a family seeking accountability, but it does not necessarily answer whether civil legal remedies remain available.
Civil rights litigation can involve constitutional law, federal statutes, state wrongful death law, municipal liability, immunity doctrines, evidence developed during criminal proceedings, and strict filing deadlines.
Ben Crump Law represents individuals and families in cases involving alleged police misconduct, excessive force, wrongful death, and other civil rights violations.
If your family lost a loved one during an encounter with law enforcement—even if an officer was acquitted or never criminally charged—you can contact Ben Crump Law to discuss the circumstances and learn whether civil legal options may remain available.
Call or text (844) 777-4453 or complete the firm’s free case evaluation form.