When someone dies following a police shooting, surviving family members may have questions about whether civil litigation can provide compensation for the loss.
The answer depends on the circumstances.
A fatal encounter with law enforcement can potentially involve federal civil rights claims, state wrongful death claims, survival claims, or a combination of legal theories. If liability is established, those claims may permit different categories of damages.
There is no standard settlement or verdict amount for a fatal police shooting lawsuit. The damages available depend on the claims, defendants, evidence, losses, applicable federal and state law, and other case-specific factors.
The distinction is particularly relevant following the acquittal of former Okaloosa County sheriff’s deputy Eddie Duran in the death of U.S. Air Force Senior Airman Roger Fortson.
Although Duran was found not guilty of manslaughter, Fortson’s family is continuing its separate federal civil rights lawsuit. Ben Crump Law’s statement following the verdict confirms that the family intends to continue pursuing that case in federal court. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Read what happens next in the Roger Fortson case following Eddie Duran’s acquittal.
The continuation of that litigation illustrates an important point: criminal punishment and civil compensation are separate forms of legal accountability.
What Damages Can Be Available After a Fatal Police Shooting?
The damages potentially available depend on the legal claims being pursued.
In a federal civil rights action, compensatory damages may potentially address injuries and losses caused by a constitutional violation.
When the person dies, state wrongful death and survival laws can also affect which damages may be pursued, who can bring the claims, and how the recovery is distributed.
Depending on the circumstances and applicable law, damages may potentially involve:
- medical expenses incurred before death;
- funeral and burial expenses;
- lost income or financial support;
- loss of services;
- pain and suffering experienced before death when recoverable;
- emotional or other non-economic losses recognized by applicable law;
- losses suffered by qualifying surviving family members; and
- punitive damages against certain individual defendants when the required legal standard is established.
Not every category is available in every case.
An attorney must determine which federal and state claims apply before the potential damages can be meaningfully evaluated.
What Are Compensatory Damages in a Police Shooting Lawsuit?
Compensatory damages are intended to compensate plaintiffs for legally recognized injuries and losses caused by wrongful conduct.
They differ from criminal penalties.
Sending someone to prison does not compensate a family for the economic and non-economic consequences of losing a loved one. Civil litigation can provide a separate mechanism for pursuing those losses when liability is established.
Compensatory damages can generally be divided into economic and non-economic losses.
What Economic Damages May Be Available?
Economic damages involve financial losses that can often be documented or calculated.
Depending on applicable law, a fatal police shooting claim may involve evidence concerning:
- medical bills;
- emergency treatment;
- hospitalization;
- funeral and burial costs;
- lost wages before death;
- future lost earnings;
- loss of financial support; and
- other measurable financial losses.
Future economic losses can require expert analysis.
For example, economists may examine the deceased person’s age, occupation, income history, employment prospects, expected work life, benefits, and financial contributions when those matters are legally relevant.
The recoverable categories depend on the claims and jurisdiction.
What Noneconomic Damages May Be Available?
Not every consequence of a fatal shooting can be measured through bills or wage records.
Depending on the applicable law and the claim, noneconomic damages may address losses that lack a direct market price.
These may include legally recognized damages for pain and suffering, emotional harm, or losses experienced by qualifying surviving family members.
State wrongful death laws differ substantially in how these damages are defined and who may recover them.
For that reason, families should not assume that damages available in one state—or in another family’s lawsuit—will necessarily be available in their case.
Ben Crump Law provides additional information about wrongful death claims.
What Is a Survival Claim After a Fatal Police Shooting?
A survival claim and a wrongful death claim are not necessarily the same thing.
Generally, survival law allows certain claims of the deceased to continue through an estate or another legally authorized representative.
Wrongful death law generally addresses particular losses arising from the person’s death.
The distinction can affect which damages are available.
For example, depending on applicable law and the evidence, a survival claim may raise questions about injuries the person experienced between the unlawful conduct and death.
Wrongful death damages may instead focus on losses recognized by state law because the person died.
Federal civil rights claims can intersect with these state-law rules, making the damages analysis particularly fact- and jurisdiction-specific.
Can You Recover Damages Under Section 1983?
Potentially.
42 U.S.C. § 1983 provides a mechanism for pursuing certain civil claims against people who, while acting under color of state law, violate federally protected rights.
A fatal police shooting lawsuit might allege that an officer used excessive force in violation of the U.S. Constitution.
If the plaintiff establishes a constitutional violation and proves that the violation caused compensable harm, damages may potentially be available.
Section 1983 does not, however, create an automatic payment simply because someone was injured or killed during an encounter with police.
The plaintiff must establish the underlying constitutional violation and the other elements required for the claim.
People researching these claims can learn more about how a civil rights lawyer may investigate alleged constitutional violations involving law enforcement.
Can a Family Recover Damages if the Police Officer Was Acquitted?
Potentially.
A criminal acquittal does not automatically eliminate a separate civil claim.
Criminal and civil proceedings involve different legal questions, burdens of proof, and remedies.
That distinction is central to the current Roger Fortson litigation.
Former Okaloosa County sheriff’s deputy Eddie Duran was acquitted of manslaughter in Fortson’s death. But Fortson’s family had already filed a separate federal civil rights lawsuit against Duran, Okaloosa County Sheriff Eric Aden, and others. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Following the criminal verdict, attorney Ben Crump said:
“Roger’s life and his service will always matter. His family will keep fighting for him, and we will stand with them as they pursue their civil rights case in federal court and seek accountability for the tragic loss of his life.”
Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Read Ben Crump’s complete response to the Eddie Duran verdict.
Whether that civil case ultimately results in liability or damages will be determined through the separate federal litigation.
For a more detailed explanation of the underlying legal distinction, see:
Can You File a Civil Rights Lawsuit After a Police Officer Is Acquitted?
Can a Family Recover Damages if the Officer Was Never Charged?
Potentially.
The same basic distinction can apply when prosecutors decide not to file criminal charges.
Prosecutors evaluate whether the evidence supports a criminal prosecution under the applicable criminal law and burden of proof.
Civil attorneys may be evaluating different causes of action under different standards.
As a result, the absence of criminal charges does not necessarily establish that:
- no constitutional violation occurred;
- no wrongful death claim exists;
- no civil defendant can be liable; or
- no damages can be recovered.
Each potential civil claim requires an independent evaluation.
The same principle can apply when a grand jury declines charges, charges are dismissed, or a criminal trial results in an acquittal.
Can Punitive Damages Be Awarded in a Police Civil Rights Lawsuit?
Potentially, but punitive damages differ significantly from compensatory damages.
Compensatory damages are intended to address legally recognized injuries and losses.
Punitive damages are intended to punish and deter particularly wrongful conduct.
Under federal civil rights law, punitive damages may be available against an individual defendant when the conduct satisfies the applicable legal standard.
They are not automatically available whenever a constitutional violation is established.
The evidence must support the additional standard required for punitive damages.
Can You Recover Punitive Damages From a City or Sheriff’s Department?
This is an important limitation.
Under federal §1983 law, municipalities generally are not subject to punitive damages.
That does not mean a city, county, or other local government can never face civil liability.
It means municipal liability and punitive damages are separate issues.
Federal claims against municipalities have their own requirements, and a local government is not automatically liable merely because it employed the officer involved.
State-law claims can also be subject to different rules, immunities, limitations, and damages provisions.
Identifying the correct defendants is therefore an important part of evaluating potential compensation.
When Can a City or County Be Liable for a Police Shooting?
A local government is generally not automatically responsible under §1983 for every constitutional violation committed by an employee.
Municipal liability can require evidence connecting the alleged constitutional violation to a legally sufficient municipal policy, custom, practice, decision, or other recognized basis for liability.
Depending on the allegations, attorneys may investigate issues involving:
- written use-of-force policies;
- training;
- supervision;
- discipline;
- prior complaints;
- previous similar incidents;
- departmental customs or practices; and
- decisions by officials with relevant policymaking authority.
These claims can require extensive evidence beyond what occurred during the immediate encounter.
That distinction can also affect damages because the defendants legally responsible for a claim can influence what remedies are available.
What Damages Is the Roger Fortson Family Seeking?
The supplied October 2 Ben Crump Law press release does not specify the amount or complete categories of damages sought in the Fortson family’s federal lawsuit.
It confirms that the family filed the federal civil rights action in May 2025 against Duran, Sheriff Eric Aden, and others, and that the litigation is separate from Duran’s criminal trial. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Accordingly, the outcome of that litigation should not be predicted, nor should a damages figure be assigned to the case based on results in unrelated police-shooting lawsuits.
The relevant point for families researching their own legal options is that the acquittal does not itself determine whether civil damages may be available.
How Much Is a Fatal Police Shooting Lawsuit Worth?
There is no reliable average settlement or verdict that can determine what a particular fatal police shooting case is worth.
Published verdicts can vary dramatically.
Settlement amounts can also differ based on the legal claims, evidence, defendants, jurisdiction, injuries, available insurance or indemnification, procedural posture, and other circumstances.
Factors that may affect potential damages include:
The Claims That Can Be Established
A federal excessive-force claim can involve different damages questions from a state wrongful death or negligence claim.
The Person’s Economic Losses
Income, employment history, future earning capacity, financial contributions, and other economic evidence may be relevant where recoverable.
The Evidence
Body-camera footage, medical evidence, eyewitness accounts, forensic evidence, and expert testimony can affect both liability and damages.
The Defendants
Claims against individual officers and claims against municipalities can involve different liability rules and available remedies.
State Law
Wrongful death and survival statutes vary significantly from state to state.
Punitive Damages
Punitive damages can substantially affect a verdict when legally available and supported by the evidence, but they cannot simply be assumed.
Does a Large Police Misconduct Verdict Mean Another Family Can Recover the Same Amount?
No.
Results in other cases can demonstrate the types of civil remedies courts and juries have considered, but they do not establish the value of a different claim.
Every case involves its own:
- facts;
- injuries;
- evidence;
- defendants;
- causes of action;
- jurisdiction;
- defenses; and
- damages.
A large verdict in one civil rights case, therefore, should not be treated as a calculator for another case.
Ben Crump Law publishes examples of previous case results, but prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome in another matter.
What Evidence Helps Prove Damages After a Fatal Police Shooting?
Establishing liability is only one part of a civil case.
Plaintiffs must also prove the damages they are legally entitled to recover.
Evidence can potentially include:
- medical records and bills;
- employment records;
- tax and income records;
- funeral and burial expenses;
- photographs and video;
- autopsy and forensic evidence;
- expert testimony;
- economic projections;
- testimony from family members and other witnesses; and
- other documentation of legally compensable losses.
The particular evidence required depends on the damages being claimed.
For example, an economist may be needed to evaluate future financial losses, while medical or forensic experts may address injuries and causation.
Is a Police Shooting Settlement the Same as a Verdict?
No.
A settlement generally occurs when the parties agree to resolve claims without requiring a judge or jury to decide the ultimate disputed issues at trial.
A verdict is reached after the claims are adjudicated.
A settlement does not necessarily constitute an admission of wrongdoing unless the agreement says otherwise.
A verdict can also be subject to post-trial motions, appeals, or other proceedings.
For SEO and consumer information purposes, this distinction matters because phrases such as “police shooting settlement,” “civil rights verdict,” and “lawsuit damages” should not be treated as interchangeable legal outcomes.
How Does a Civil Rights Attorney Evaluate Damages?
Evaluating potential damages requires more than identifying that a shooting occurred.
An attorney may need to determine:
- what happened and what evidence establishes it;
- whether a constitutional or other legal violation can be proven;
- which defendants may legally be responsible;
- whether federal civil rights claims are available;
- which wrongful death or survival laws apply;
- what economic and non-economic losses can be established;
- whether punitive damages may legally be pursued;
- what defenses or immunities may apply; and
- which filing and notice deadlines control the case.
Only after those issues are investigated can potential damages be evaluated meaningfully.
The Roger Fortson Case Illustrates the Difference Between Criminal Punishment and Civil Recovery
Roger Fortson was 23 years old and assigned to the 4th Special Operations Squadron at Hurlburt Field when Duran shot and killed him at his Fort Walton Beach apartment on May 3, 2024. Fortson – Duran NG Statement
Duran subsequently faced a criminal manslaughter prosecution and was acquitted.
Fortson’s family is pursuing its federal civil rights litigation separately.
Those proceedings serve different legal functions.
The criminal trial addressed criminal guilt.
The federal civil lawsuit can address separate questions of civil liability and, if liability is established, legally recoverable damages.
For the complete current-news chronology, read:
Eddie Duran Acquitted: What Happens Next in the Roger Fortson Case?
For the legal issue raised by the acquittal, read:
Can You File a Civil Rights Lawsuit After a Police Officer Is Acquitted?
For the Fortson family’s response to the verdict, read:
Attorney Ben Crump Responds to Verdict in Death of Senior Airman Roger Fortson
Together, these resources move from the current development to the legal question created by the acquittal and then to the potential civil remedies available when liability is established.
Talk to a Civil Rights Attorney About a Fatal Police Shooting
Fatal police shooting cases can involve overlapping constitutional law, §1983 litigation, wrongful death statutes, survival claims, municipal liability, immunity doctrines, and damages law.
The outcome of a criminal prosecution does not necessarily answer all of those civil questions.
Ben Crump Law represents individuals and families in matters involving alleged excessive force, police misconduct, wrongful death, and other civil rights violations.
If your family lost a loved one during an encounter with law enforcement, you can contact Ben Crump Law to discuss the circumstances and learn whether civil legal options may be available.
Call or text (844) 777-4453 or complete the firm’s free case evaluation form.