The fatal police shooting of 39-year-old Montique Treymayne Gaston in Staunton, Virginia, remains under investigation as community leaders call for more information about what happened.
Gaston, a Portsmouth resident, was shot and killed on September 22, 2026, after a Staunton Police Department officer responded to a Walmart parking lot off Richmond Avenue. Police said the officer made contact with Gaston after a citizen called 911 and that an altercation occurred before the officer fired. https://www.whsv.com
Gaston was pronounced dead at the scene despite lifesaving efforts by the officer involved and additional officers who arrived afterward. The Staunton officer was not injured and was placed on administrative leave while the shooting is investigated. https://www.whsv.com
Authorities have released a few details about what led to the use of deadly force.
That lack of information has become a central issue in the case.
Virginia State Police Are Conducting an Independent Investigation
The Staunton Police Department asked the Virginia State Police to investigate the shooting.
According to local reporting, once the state investigation is complete, the case is expected to be reviewed by a special prosecutor. https://www.whsv.com
Police Chief Jim Williams later disclosed that the officer involved was wearing a body camera and that the device recorded the entire encounter. The footage has been turned over to the Virginia State Police as part of the investigation. https://www.whsv.com
As of October 7, authorities have not publicly released that video.
The officer’s identity also has not been publicly disclosed in the available reporting.
Staunton NAACP Calls for Transparency and Answers
The Staunton branch of the NAACP has publicly raised concerns about the amount of information available to Gaston’s family and the community.
Following a statement from the organization, Staunton officials met with local NAACP leadership to discuss the shooting and the status of the investigation.
NAACP branch president Nadia Ware told WHSV that the organization wants to ensure the investigation moves forward in a timely manner and that Gaston’s family and the community receive answers. https://www.whsv.com
The City of Staunton said after the meeting that officials are committed to maintaining an open dialogue and supporting the preservation of evidence while Virginia State Police continue their independent investigation. https://www.whsv.com
Residents have also called for the release of the body-camera footage and greater transparency surrounding the encounter. https://www.whsv.com
Why Body-Camera Footage Could Be Critical
Body-camera footage can become one of the most important forms of evidence after a fatal police shooting.
Depending on the camera angle and quality, video may help establish:
- what happened before officers used force
- whether Gaston was armed
- what commands did the officer give
- whether Gaston complied or attempted to comply
- the distance between Gaston and the officer
- Gaston’s movements immediately before the shooting
- whether the officer perceived an immediate threat
- how many shots were fired
- what occurred immediately after the shooting
Video evidence is not always conclusive.
Body cameras may not capture everything an officer saw, and camera placement, movement, obstructions, lighting, and audio can affect how an encounter appears.
For that reason, investigators and civil-rights attorneys may also examine surveillance footage, witness statements, 911 recordings, police radio traffic, forensic evidence, autopsy findings, and physical evidence from the scene.
Ben Crump Law has handled numerous police-misconduct cases in which body-camera footage became central evidence.
For example, the firm recently released body-camera footage in the fatal shooting of Saveion McConnell, arguing that the video contradicted the justification for the use of deadly force and showed shots being fired after McConnell had fallen to the ground. Ben Crump
Ben Crump Law has also relied on body-camera evidence in the Shahzad Gaziani case, where the firm alleges Houston police used excessive deadly force while Gaziani was experiencing a mental-health crisis. Ben Crump
These are separate cases with different facts and legal standards, but they illustrate the role video evidence can play when accounts of a police encounter are disputed.
What Questions Remain in the Montique Gaston Shooting?
Several basic questions remain unanswered publicly.
Among them:
- What prompted the original 911 call?
- What happened when the officer encountered Gaston?
- What did the police mean by an “altercation”?
- Was Gaston armed?
- Did police issue commands before shots were fired?
- How much time passed between first contact and the shooting?
- Was any less-lethal force attempted?
- What does the body-camera footage show?
- Are there surveillance cameras in the Walmart parking lot?
- Were independent witnesses present?
- How many shots were fired?
- What does the autopsy or forensic evidence show?
Those questions matter both to the criminal investigation and to any potential civil-rights review.
When Can a Fatal Police Shooting Lead to a Civil Rights Claim?
A fatal police shooting does not automatically establish that an officer violated the law.
Police officers are permitted to use deadly force when the applicable legal standards are met.
However, a family may have grounds to investigate a civil-rights claim if evidence indicates that an officer used constitutionally excessive force.
Important factors may include:
- whether the person posed an immediate threat
- whether a weapon was present
- whether the person was advancing or retreating
- the amount of time available to the officer
- whether warnings were given
- whether the person had an opportunity to comply
- whether the officer continued using force after the threat ended
- what video and forensic evidence show
Ben Crump Law’s police shooting practice page addresses potential claims arising from fatal and nonfatal police shootings.
Its broader civil rights practice addresses constitutional claims involving alleged police misconduct and excessive force.
Families may also need to evaluate possible wrongful-death claims after police excessive force.
Body-Camera Release Can Become a Major Issue for Families
Families often want to see body-camera footage quickly after a fatal police encounter.
Whether and when they can obtain it can depend on:
- state public-records laws
- whether the investigation remains active
- prosecutor requests
- privacy restrictions
- court orders
- department policies
- litigation discovery
The fact that footage exists does not necessarily mean it will be released publicly immediately.
That issue is particularly relevant in the Gaston case because Staunton police have confirmed that the entire incident was recorded, while community members and the NAACP continue to seek greater transparency. https://www.whsv.com
Related: Police Body Camera Footage After a Fatal Shooting: Can Families Get the Video?
That will be Article 2 in this cluster.
Ben Crump Law’s Experience With Police Body-Camera and Transparency Cases
Ben Crump Law has repeatedly represented families seeking access to evidence and accountability after law-enforcement encounters.
Recent examples include:
- Saveion McConnell — body-camera footage released by the legal team after a fatal police shooting. Ben Crump
- Shahzad Gaziani — body-camera footage reviewed in connection with a fatal shooting during a mental-health crisis. Ben Crump
- Eboni Pouncy — Crump publicly responded to newly released body-camera footage after deputies shot Pouncy multiple times. Ben Crump
- Rhyker Earl — the firm called for the release of body-camera footage following a fatal law-enforcement encounter during a medical emergency. Ben Crump
There is also a useful Virginia-specific authority bridge: Ben Crump Law filed a $25 million civil suit in 2026 involving the death of Rolin Hill in Virginia Beach, alleging excessive force by deputies during a mental-health crisis. Ben Crump
I would use that link selectively because it gives this cluster something the Cave cluster lacked: documented BCL civil-rights litigation within Virginia itself.
What Happens Next?
Virginia State Police will continue investigating the shooting and reviewing the evidence, including the officer’s body-camera recording.
According to initial reports, a special prosecutor is expected to review the case once the state investigation concludes. https://www.whsv.com
The Staunton NAACP has said it also intends to communicate with the Virginia State Police as it continues seeking answers. https://www.whsv.com
Until investigators release additional evidence, important facts surrounding the shooting remain unknown.
Ben Crump Law Handles Police Shooting and Civil Rights Cases
Ben Crump Law represents individuals and families in cases involving alleged:
- police shootings
- excessive force
- wrongful death
- police misconduct
- constitutional violations
- failures of police accountability
A civil-rights attorney can independently evaluate body-camera footage, witness testimony, forensic evidence, police policies, and other records to determine whether legal claims may exist.
If you or a loved one has been seriously injured or killed during an encounter with law enforcement, contact Ben Crump Law for a free case evaluation.